Pay Closer Attention: Boys are Struggling Academically

-- USA TODAY December 3, 2004


Girls are taking the nation's colleges by storm. They're streaming to campuses in greater numbers, earning better grades and graduating more often. The same phenomenal success shows in high schools, where girls dominate honor rolls, hold more student government spots and rake in most of the academic awards.

So says a just-released report from the U.S. Department of Education.

Impressive. But the real news is tucked into the deeper, darker corners of the report. Boys are doing miserably, and nobody knows quite why. On measures ranging from writing ability to the likelihood of needing special education, boys are flat-lining — or worse.

The phenomenon is most serious in inner cities, but it's evident in even the wealthiest school districts. And it's not confined to the United States. The same trend is turning up throughout the industrialized world.

The impact could hardly be overstated. College-educated people earn twice as much as high school graduates. If boys can't get to the good-jobs starting line, which these days is a bachelor's degree, they won't get a chance to use their natural competitive skills in the marketplace.

And when fewer men earn college degrees there are fewer partners whom educated women find desirable to marry. That's a debilitating social phenomenon African-American women have struggled with for years.

The problem has already grown so severe that three out of every four private colleges (an informal estimate from admissions directors) quietly practice affirmative action for boys, favoring them over girls in admissions to get near balance.

Yet for most educators — from kindergarten on up — the problem is invisible. Any teacher looking for national research that might define classroom solutions won't find any. They don't exist.

The small group of experts who research the problem only now is beginning to trace its outlines.

It isn't so much that schools have changed in ways that hurt boys. It's that society has changed in ways that help girls.

Increasingly, success requires verbal skills, which everyone agrees come more naturally to girls. Industrial-age jobs that required minimal verbal skills are disappearing, replaced by information-age jobs that range from filing insurance claims to law. Even in technical fields, verbal skills are at a premium. An auto mechanic or TV repairman now needs to master complex technical manuals.

School reformers eventually spotted the need and reacted strongly, setting standards and writing tests that demand verbal skills. The SAT and ACT required for college applicants, for instance, now have an essay component.

This puts boys at a huge handicap, and schools haven't begun to adapt.

One hint of the inadequacy can be found in research done by Michael Gurian, author of Boys and Girls Learn Differently. He surveyed the course offerings of schools of education throughout the country. His discovery: 99% of universities and teacher colleges do not offer a course on the biological differences between how girls and boys learn. So teachers enter classrooms unprepared to turn boys into successful readers.

Other factors also come quickly into play, setting off a downward spiral that looks something like this: At home, dads read to their daughters and throw footballs to their sons. In elementary school overwhelmingly female teaching staffs naturally teach in ways that connect better with girls. Fidgety boys are quickly defined as suffering from reading disabilities. In middle school, teachers — still unattuned to the boys' disadvantages — take no action to correct swelling reading gaps.

That brings boys to the pivotal ninth grade, the first year when they run up against the heavily verbal, college-track curriculum that school reforms demand of most schools. And the boys flounder.

The trend holds through the remaining school years: Girls shine; boys fade.

Some responses suggested by researchers appear easy. Assign boys books that they find more appealing, for example. And bring them along gradually, so they don't quit.

But in the end, the problem runs much deeper. It surely won't be fixed until educators first come to see that it exists.

WHAT OTHERS ARE SAYING:

Rod Paige, U.S. Education secretary: "The good news is that girls have narrowed or completely erased the educational learning gap with boys. Unfortunately, boys now seem to be falling behind, and this is particularly a problem in minority communities. The key is early support and intervention."

Michael Gurian, author, Boys and Girls Learn Differently : "Our schools of education — including those at many of our most prestigious universities — don't train young teachers in the biological differences between how boys and girls learn. The teachers are therefore not fully prepared to take on boys' minds in schools. Our school classrooms themselves — at all grade levels — favor the female mind's way of acquiring and processing information. Many boys are simply set up not to succeed."

Robert Massa, admissions director, Dickinson College: "After centuries of under representation in higher education, women have been actively encouraged — appropriately so — to attend. The parallel encouragement of men has been lacking. With an increase in single-parent households, the lack of male role models in education, and a slower maturity rate for boys, we can understand why men have fallen significantly behind women in college attendance rates.

"Barbara Sprung, co-director, Educational Equity Concepts: "Boys pick up cues from the world around them — from the toys they are given to the TV programs they watch — that reading and writing are more for girls than boys. This attitude has negative consequences for their future education. The problem begins before kindergarten."


 




National News Stories concerning the Gurian Institute National Stories

Nurture the Nature Parenting Philosophy is featured in USA TODAY.  
Click here for the article.

Newsweek cover story explores boys' needs in school. 
Click here for the article.

Gurian Institute Research In The Washington Post. The national media calls attention to the alarming male/female schooling gap.
Click here for the article.

MarketWatch voices concern about boys falling behind in the academic world. Click here for the article.

Wall Street Journal - National attention brought to concept of parents beyond parents. Click here for the article.

Gurian Institute Research In USA TODAY. The national media calls attention to boy/girl learning differences. Click here for the article.

 National Boys' Crisis in Education Addressed in USA TODAY.
Click here for the article.

NEWSWEEK article - Boy Brains, Girl Brains; Are Separate Classrooms The Best Way to Teach Kids? Click here for the article.

Scholastic.com - Michael Gurian teaches parents how to nurture the nature of each child. Click here for the article.

Fatherhood Project. Michael shares thoughts and reflections on the impact his own father had on his development. Click here.



National News Stories concerning the Gurian Institute Professional Journals

American School Board Journal - Gurian Institute work is featured in the cover story of the American School Board Journal. Click here for the article.

American Counseling Association -
Do Great Minds Really Think Alike?
Click here for the article.

ASCD Gurian Institute Educational Leadership Article #1. Click here for the article.

 Education News - Michael Gurian discusses NURTURE THE NATURE with educators and parents. Click here for the article.

ASCD Gurian Institute Educational Leadership Article #2. Click here for the article.

An Interview in Education World with Michael Gurian. Click here for the article.

One of Canada's leading educational magazines features Gurian Institute methodologies. Executive Director Kathy Stevens, appeared in Primary Leadership. Professional Journal of the BC Primary Teachers Association. Vol. 7, No. 1, Spring 04. Click here for the article.




National News Stories concerning the Gurian Institute Regional Stories

The Connection Newspapers - (Mount Vernon, VA) - Elementary school tries single gender classes. Click here for the article.

Tulsa Kids Magazine - (Tulsa, OK) - Nurture the Nature featured in cover story.  Click here for the article.

The Tampa Tribune - (Tampa Bay, FL) - Tampa Bay Schools Use Gurian Institute Resources to Improve Grades. Click here for the article.

Gainesville Times - (Gainesville, GA) - Gurian Institute Trainer helps Florida Schools.  Click here for the article.

 Gurian Institute Helps School In Alabama. Click here for the article.

Gurian Institute Trainer Peggy Daniels reports on Success in North Carolina. Article was published in the Asheville Citizen Times.  (This is a PDF file. Get Adobe Reader for free hereIf you have Adobe Reader - Click here for the article.

 A Crisis in the Classroom For Boys. Educators say changes need to be made now. (This is a PDF file. Get Adobe Reader for free hereIf you have Adobe Reader - Click here for the article.

San Francisco Chronicle - (San Francisco, CA) - Gender Issues and the Gurian Institute are featured in the San Francisco Chronicle.  Click here for the article.

 From the Houston Chronicle:  Breakthrough Book Gives Answers Why Boys Will Be Boys. Click here for the article.

 Gurian Institute's Kathy Steven's is interviewed. Click here for the article.

Houston School Becomes Gurian Institute Model School. Click here for the article.

The Daytona Beach News-Journal (Daytona, FL) - Florida school succeeds with Gurian Institute training and new model. Click here for the article.

The Coastal Courier (Hinesville, GA) - Georgia schools utilize Gurian Institute techniques. Click here for the article.

Birmingham Post-Herald (Birmingham, Al) - Alabama schools utilize Gurian Institute Techniques. Click here for the article.

The Birmingham News (Birmingham, Al) - Alabama schools utilize Gurian Institute Techniques. Click here for the article.

The Gazette  (Colorado Springs, CO)Kathy Stevens receives Womens Resource Award. Click here for the article.




National News Stories concerning the Gurian Institute International News

 The Philippines Post - Schools Hope To Address Worldwide Problem.  Click here for the article.











Home    About Us    Education    Corporate    Family 
   Human Services    Success    Biographies    Michael Gurian  • 
Articles   
Books & Tapes    Training DVDs    Research   
Advisors    Speaking Schedule

Join our mailing list Join Our Mailing List              Contact the Gurian Institute Contact Us